Wednesday, January 9, 2013

Lower Realization -- Sometimes an Acceptable Tradeoff

Parsley Sage Rosemary & Ginsburg LLP
“Always a reasonable result for a reasonable fee, always”
MEMORANDUM

To:
Managing Partners; Practice Group Leaders
From:
Mike Marget
Date:
January 9, 2013
Re:
Lower Realization – Sometimes an Acceptable Tradeoff 

Since the onset of the recession, clients have gained the advantage in fee negotiations.  Yet Legal Industrial Complex firms still managed to increase their hourly rates in 2012.  According to a survey published last month by The National Law Journal, median partner rates jumped 4.5% to $517 an hour and median associate rates increased 3.5% to $323.  The survey covered 55 firms ranging in size from 128 to 3,000+ lawyers.

While these rates may not resonate with your particular practice, it is a prudent business exercise to review pricing issues from time-to-time.  

Over the years I’ve had “discussions” with partners and practice group leaders who prided themselves on high realization.  They seldom needed to write-down time, collecting 98%-99% as compared to their standard hourly rates.  High realization percentages are wonderful when you are absolutely certain those rates are at the ceiling as to what the market will bear.  But such certainty, you should be bold and sacrifice a few realization percentage points in a quest for higher aggregate fees.  Let me demonstrate how this is important.

Assume you work 1,800 billable hours a year; have a $250 standard hourly rate; and enjoy 98% realization.  You will collect $441,000 on your work. [1,800 x $250 x 98% = $441,000]  Digging into the details of your practice reveals 900 of those hours are worked and collected at your standard $250 hourly rate, while the balance is for more rate-sensitive clients who are charged $240.  (This is illustrated in Example 1.) 

Then further assume, you decide to test drive a 4% rate increase on your standard rate, pushing it to $260 an hour. 

What is the worst that could happen?  Your rate-sensitive clients balk at the increase, so those hours remain at $240.  Theoretically, you could lose the other 900 hours if the new $260 rate is too high.  But in the real world, you are a lawyer and everything is negotiable.  If necessary, you’ll discount the new $260 standard rate with the pitch, “My standard rate is $260, but for you … $250.”  As illustrated in Example 2, you will still generate $441,000 in revenue even though your realization has dropped to 94.2%.  In essence, you enjoy the same revenue stream despite a lower realization statistic. 

On the other hand, if you manage just 1 additional hour at a rate higher than $250, you are ahead.

What is the best case scenario?  Assume you get the 4% increase on all your time currently billed at $250 an hour.  This is illustrated in Example 3.  The additional $10 an hour jumps your total revenue up to $450,000.  However, due to the $20 an hour negative spread between your new standard rate of $260 and the $240-an-hour cap on half your time, your realization drops to 96.2%.  Again, you achieve higher revenue despite the lower realization rate.

There is also an alternative almost-best case scenario.  Assume you cannot replace all 900 hours at the new higher standard rate?  Instead of 900 billable hours at $260 an hour, you produce only 865.  No worries, I’d still call this a win.  See Example 4.  With these numbers you are still generating the same $441,000 of revenue, but need to work only 1,765 billable hours in the process.  Sure, your realization drops to 96.1%, but the lower number of billable hours provides you 35 additional hours without any revenue decline.  That’s 35 free hours to devote to business development efforts which will eventually generate new work and create incremental revenue.

 
Example 1
Example 2
Example 3
 Example 4
Standard hourly rate
$250
$260
$260
$260
$240/hr clients
 
 
 
 
Billable hours
900
900
900
900
Effective hourly rate
$240
$240
$240
$240
Fee revenue generated
$ 216,000
$ 216,000
$ 216,000
$ 216,000
Other clients
 
 
 
 
Billable hours
900
900
900
865
Effective hourly rate
$250
$250
$260
$260
Fee revenue generated
$ 225,000
$ 225,000
$ 234,000
$ 225,000
Result
 
 
 
 
Billable hours
1800
1800
1800
1765
Effective hourly rate
$245
$245
$250
$ 250
Fee revenue generated
$ 441,000
$ 441,000
$ 450,000
$ 441,000
Realization rate
98.0%
94.2%
96.2%
96.1%

Now, I’m not about to paraphrase Dick Cheney and say “realization rates don’t matter.”  Rather, the point is realization rates, like deficits, need to be evaluated in a larger economic context.  Higher rates may mean higher write-offs and lower billable hours – but what is important is the bottom line. 

Maybe a higher standard rate for new clients simply becomes a starting point for fee discussion in 2013.  After all, a 10% discount from $260 an hour is preferable to discounting from $250.  Like the aphorism says, “If you don’t ask, you don’t get.”  Sometimes you do get! 

4 comments:

  1. (Cheap Yeezys For Sale) particular litigation could run 50% longer, Together with income taxing present when nova scotia. A regular great made of constructed from wool go well with goes relating to $450 in Hong Kong.

    No person that has half a head into their leads will certainly refuse because during eight five to ten a lifetime the two of us experienced some amazingly noxious and (Coach Outlet Store Online) moreover sinister many years, (Michael Kors Outlet Store) For the become old having to deal with number possibility (Jordan Shoes For Sale Online) but to think customers connected with management disappointments is before long only probably still (Ray Ban Outlet Store) in. We were a fairly enjoyable long term above, Loaded (New Yeezys 2020) with domestic and (Cheap Jordan Shoes Websites) private tests, Since bonk the following, I have on want to hang about until december. I starting out rejoice in (Yeezy Boost 350 Cheap) at this instant.

    ReplyDelete
  2. We have a List of Girls who are in financial problems. They need your help. They are ready to sleep with you in some small amounts. Call us for their contact no and help them. To book an escort just drop a call to the given number and ask them what kind of service you want!. You will also WhatsApp us for the availability of ourEscorts Service in Amausi, LucknowIf you’re in the end determined and ready to enjoy the amusing of being at duration the corporate of one of our beautiful girls. Check our other Services...
    Escorts Service in Aram Bagh Agra
    Escorts Service in Arjunganj, Lucknow
    Escorts Service in Badarpur
    Escorts Service in Badarpur
    Escorts Service in Badarpur
    Escorts Service in Badarpur
    Escorts Service in Badarpur

    ReplyDelete
  3. Asked in Business Finance, Coach Outlet Coach Outlet Store The Difference Between, Legal New Jordan Shoes 2020 Definitions What is the difference between margin and margin?Profit margins are important if your suppliers keep raising Yeezy Discount the price of the product you need to sell or product you need for manufacturing. Margins are the differnt changes in the cost to profit percentages. If you buy a case of cookies for 5 dollars and sell them each for 10 dollars profit Ray Ban Glasses percentage is a 200 % or 50 Ray Ban Outlet % mark up.

    The ISES training principles provide Coach Handbags Clearance an excellent starting point for professionals and horse owners. Currently, there does not seem to be an accepted protocol for evaluating horse training programs against the ISES Yeezy Boost 350 principles. We suggest an approach to this, using Parelli Natural Horsemanship as our subject for evaluation.

    ReplyDelete